The Intermediary Trap: From Market Makers to Market Takers

Written By: DKeith Wilson

From merchants to algorithms, the story of intermediaries is about who controls the relationship, the data and the customer—and in the digital age that control lies mostly with aggregators and platforms, not the producers and brands.
In this Article

The Disintermediation Myth

Software was supposed to kill the middleman.

That was the promise. As the web grew up, it told a compelling story: remove the friction, cut out the brokers, and put buyers directly in touch with sellers. It sounded like freedom—and for a time, it was. Anyone could start a store, sell a product, share a message.

But the story didn’t end there.

What really happened wasn’t disintermediation. It was re-intermediation. Middlemen didn’t vanish—they became invisible, faster, and far more powerful. The difference? You stopped noticing them. Or worse, you started depending on them.

The modern business doesn’t just live in a market. It lives within a system someone else built—and controls. And most don’t even realize it.

This essay is about those systems.
The visible ones. The hidden ones.
And why every business—especially small ones—should take a much closer look at who stands between them and their customer.

Middlemen 1.0 — The Old-School Connectors

Middlemen aren’t a tech-age problem. They’re as old as trade itself.

Before we had mass manufacturing, logistics, or credit systems, the people who could connect buyers and sellers held real power. They didn’t need to own the product—they just needed to know who wanted it, and who had it.

Traders along the Silk Road, Phoenician sea merchants, spice brokers in Venice—these weren’t producers or consumers. They were value extractors. Their leverage came from geography, trust, and information scarcity.

If you were a farmer, you didn’t have reach. If you were a buyer, you didn’t have access. The middleman bridged the gap—and set the price.

As markets evolved, so did their tools:

  • Fairs and guilds gave sellers a place to gather.
  • Letters of credit reduced the need to carry gold.
  • Reputational bonds ensured you didn’t get scammed.

But the role never changed. The middleman structured the market. Without them, nothing moved.

This wasn’t inherently bad. In many cases, it created efficiency. But it also concentrated leverage. Whoever owned the road, owned the trade. Whoever controlled the exchange, controlled the price. Sound familiar?

Before we talk about algorithms and aggregators, we have to understand this:
Intermediation isn’t new. It’s a feature of every market.
The question isn’t whether it exists.
It’s who benefits from it—and who doesn’t know they’re paying the toll.

Industrial Scale — Intermediation Goes Corporate

As markets grew more complex, middlemen got institutionalized.

The rise of industrialization didn’t replace the intermediary—it scaled it. Mass production created more goods than local markets could handle. That created demand for a new type of connector: one that could reach, package, and distribute at scale.

Enter wholesalers. Retailers. Distributors. Sales reps. Catalogs.
The merchant evolved into an institution.

Companies like Sears didn’t just sell products—they organized demand. The Sears catalog wasn’t just a printed brochure. It was a logistics machine wrapped in paper. It turned physical distance into solvable distribution. It told rural America what was possible—and then delivered it to their door.

But with reach came control.

By the early 20th century, large manufacturers were no longer just making goods—they were shaping the very channels those goods traveled through. Brand trust replaced local reputation. Distribution networks replaced regional brokers. And entire industries formed around who could get shelf space, who controlled the warehouse, who negotiated the slotting fee.

Middlemen became harder to replace because they added structure. They weren’t just connecting—they were coordinating.

The same thing was happening in media. Radio stations, newspapers, and later television networks didn’t produce most of the content. They decided what got airtime. Attention was finite, and the platform decided who got seen.

This was the golden era of analog aggregation.
Every system—retail, media, entertainment, logistics—depended on centralized intermediaries to scale.

And just like their ancient counterparts, these middlemen didn’t just facilitate value. They extracted it.

The Digital Shift — Disruption or Repackaging?

When the internet arrived, it made a promise: remove the middleman.

Craigslist replaced classified ads. Shopify gave you your own storefront. eBay let you auction anything to anyone. It looked like a revolution—and in some ways, it was. Friction dropped. Distribution flattened. Margins got healthier.

But the revolution didn’t last.

As more people joined the web, new problems appeared: discovery, trust, and choice overload. Tools weren’t enough—you needed systems. Systems that sorted, filtered, ranked, and delivered. And just like before, someone had to sit in the middle to make that happen.

Amazon was the inflection point.

It started as a bookstore. It became the store. You didn’t browse sellers—you trusted the platform. Amazon didn’t just sell products. It intermediated logistics, reviews, recommendations, payments, and delivery.

Suddenly, the most powerful company in the supply chain didn’t own any of the goods. It owned the attention. The transaction. The customer.

This wasn’t disintermediation. It was abstraction.
The middleman didn’t disappear—he changed shape.
And this time, he wasn’t asking for a cut. He was designing the entire experience.

For a while, we told ourselves this was different. Platforms were neutral. They just connected users. But over time, it became clear: the more value the platform provided, the more control it demanded.

Software didn’t remove the middle layer.
It made the new layer indispensable.

Aggregation Theory — Power Without Ownership

Ben Thompson’s Aggregation Theory gives us the clearest lens for what really changed.

Traditional intermediaries made money by controlling supply—owning inventory, warehouses, storefronts. Aggregators flipped the model. They don’t own the products. They don’t employ the producers. They don’t even set the prices.

They own something far more valuable: the relationship with the demand side.

According to Thompson, aggregators follow three defining patterns:

  1. Direct relationships with users
    They serve the end consumer directly—and own that trust.
  2. Zero marginal cost of distribution
    Unlike physical retail, they don’t need new infrastructure to scale.
  3. Supply-side commoditization
    Every supplier on the platform is interchangeable. The aggregator doesn’t care who wins—as long as the user stays.

Google doesn’t write content—it decides what gets seen.
Facebook doesn’t create media—it decides what gets amplified.
Amazon doesn’t manufacture the goods—it decides what gets bought.

The result is brutal leverage.

Aggregators become the default interface for entire industries. Consumers think they’re making choices. Businesses think they’re gaining access. But in reality, both are playing inside someone else’s system.

And the more the aggregator learns—clicks, conversions, behavior—the stronger its position gets. Each transaction reinforces the platform’s dominance.

This is what makes Aggregation Theory so important. It’s not just about business models. It’s about power.
Power that scales exponentially.
Power that doesn’t look like a middleman—until it’s too late.

The Rise of Algorithmic Intermediaries

The aggregator wasn’t the final form. It was the gateway drug.

As platforms scaled, a new layer of intermediation emerged—one that didn’t just organize supply and demand, but interpreted it.
Curation became automation. Recommendations became algorithms. Choice became prediction.

The new middleman isn’t a person or a company. It’s code.
And that code decides what you see, what you click, what you buy, and in many cases, what you think is even available.

This is where intermediaries stop being visible at all.

You don’t scroll to page 2 of Google. You don’t wonder why that one restaurant shows up first on DoorDash. You don’t question why your YouTube feed serves the same 6 topics. The algorithm intermediates everything—attention, trust, perception, demand.

And the feedback loop is vicious:

  • The more users engage, the more the system learns.
  • The more it learns, the more it controls visibility.
  • The more it controls visibility, the harder it is to compete.

What’s being sold isn’t just access—it’s belief. The algorithm decides what’s “popular.” It decides what “people like you” want. It rewires the way demand is formed.

And the terrifying part?
It’s largely unaccountable.
There’s no appeal process when your product stops showing up. No conversation when your views drop. No human to explain when your restaurant drops off the feed.

We’re not just operating within marketplaces anymore.
We’re optimizing for systems we didn’t build—and can’t predict.

Platform Dependence and the SMB Trap

For small and midsized businesses, the danger doesn’t feel like danger. It feels like convenience.

You sign up for Uber Eats because it sends orders. You list on Amazon because it expands your reach. You run ads on Google because your competitors already are.

And at first, it works.
Until it doesn’t.

Every benefit a platform gives you comes at a cost you don’t see right away:

  • You don’t get the customer’s email.
  • You can’t remarket to them directly.
  • You don’t control the experience—or the pricing.
  • You’re ranked by a system that doesn’t explain its logic.

You’re not using the platform. You’re building your business inside of it. And once that happens, you’re no longer the owner of the relationship. You’re just one of many inputs.

The trap is slow and subtle:

  • You stop investing in your own site because the leads come from Yelp.
  • You let Amazon handle fulfillment because it’s easier than managing logistics.
  • You train your customers to expect discounts because the platform promotes coupons.

And then one day, the fees go up.
Or the rankings shift.
Or a competitor undercuts you and the algorithm decides they’re better.

And you realize: you don’t just rely on the platform.
You depend on it.

This is the trap.
The modern intermediary doesn’t ask for permission.
It just becomes too useful to ignore—until it’s too late to leave.

The Cost of Convenience

Every intermediary in history has offered the same thing: convenience.

Markets don’t choose complexity. They choose ease, scale, speed. And intermediaries—whether merchants, retailers, or platforms—deliver exactly that.

But the cost of convenience compounds.

For businesses, it starts with margin erosion.
You pay the fee. Then the advertising. Then the placement boost. Before long, you’re giving up 20–40% of your sale just to exist where your customer is looking.

Next comes loss of differentiation.
If a customer finds you through a filter, they’ll switch through a filter. You’re not a brand—they’re not loyal. You’re just a result.

Finally, you lose visibility into what matters:

  • Why customers choose you
  • How they behave after the click
  • What they’d prefer if given the choice

The more you depend on platforms, the less you own your own data.
And when you don’t own the data, you don’t own the learning.
And when you don’t own the learning, you stop evolving.

Convenience isn’t just expensive.
It’s disempowering.

The intermediary becomes your marketing, your storefront, your CRM, your analytics dashboard.
And that means your job stops being building a business—
and starts being feeding someone else’s system.

The Closing Argument — Intermediaries Aren’t the Problem. Blindness to Them Is.

This isn’t a call to eliminate intermediaries. That’s not possible.
Intermediation is a feature of all markets—always has been. What changes is who sits in that position, and how visible they are while extracting value.

The real risk isn’t platforms.
It’s building your business without understanding how much of it they already own.

Most small businesses think they’re gaining tools when they join a platform. What they’re often giving up is control—over pricing, customer data, experience, and long-term leverage.

You can’t opt out of systems.
But you can learn where the leverage is.
Who sets the rules.
Who owns the customer.
Who benefits from your growth.

Because if it’s not you—
you’re not the business.
You’re just the supply.

Stay sharp. Think bigger. Build smarter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Facebook

More Articles

Let’s get you unblocked.

Looking to talk shop?

If you are a student in our training programs needing tactical help, grab an Office Hours slot. If you’re a podcast guest or fellow creator looking to network, choose the Collaboration link.

Select your track to view my calendar.

LMS Student Office Hours

Stuck on a module or hitting a technical roadblock in one of our training programs? Grab a quick, hyper-focused 15-minute slot so we can unblock you. To make the most of our time: Please drop a link or screenshot of the exact bottleneck (e.g., your sheet, framework map, or tool setup) in the intake questions so we can dive straight into the fix.

Virtual Coffee & Collaboration

Stuck on a module or hitting a technical roadblock in one of our training programs? Grab a quick, hyper-focused 15-minute slot so we can unblock you. To make the most of our time: Please drop a link or screenshot of the exact bottleneck (e.g., your sheet, framework map, or tool setup) in the intake questions so we can dive straight into the fix.

Podcast Guest Interview: "The Y and the How"

Welcome! This slot is for confirmed guests appearing on The Y and the How podcast. We’ll spend the first 5 minutes doing a technical audio/video check, followed by a 30-minute deep dive into the high-level strategies (The Why) and the practical systems (The How) driving modern business growth. Please note: Ensure you are in a quiet room with a dedicated microphone and headphones. A Riverside connection link will be sent with your confirmation email.